There's one question we hear in our butchery every Christmas, and it's probably the most important question to get right before the big day.
"What size Turkey do I actually need?"
Buy too small and you could find yourself scraping the last few slices together on Christmas Day. Buy too big and you might be eating Turkey until New Year!
But here's something I've learnt after in excess of three centuries in butchery. The number of people sitting around your Christmas table isn't necessarily the most important thing to consider.
There's another question I always think customers should ask before deciding what size Turkey to buy.
What do you want left over for Boxing Day?
Because, personally, I think some of the best eating of Christmas happens the following day.
So, whether you're cooking for four people or fourteen, here's our practical guide to choosing the right Turkey, with a little advice from the Turnbull's butchery team along the way.
How Much Turkey Do You Need Per Person?
First, it depends on whether you're buying a traditional Whole Turkey or a Boneless Turkey Crown.
A Whole Turkey includes the legs, wings and bones, whereas a Boneless Turkey Crown is prepared from Turkey Breast with the bones removed.
That makes quite a difference when calculating how much meat you'll actually have to serve.
And while you'll find plenty of Turkey calculators online, I prefer to give customers a realistic serving range rather than one exact number.
After all, we're not all the same when it comes to Christmas dinner!
Whole Turkey Size Guide
If you're choosing a traditional Whole Turkey, here's what we'd recommend:
|
Whole Turkey Weight |
Recommended Servings |
|
4kg+ |
4–6 people |
|
6kg+ |
6–8 people |
|
7kg+ |
8–10 people |
|
8kg+ |
10–14 people |
|
9kg+ |
14–16 people |
A little advice from our butchery: If you want a generous Christmas dinner AND plenty of leftovers for Boxing Day, work towards the lower end of the serving range.
For example, a 4kg Turkey would be a lovely choice for four people, with plenty of opportunity to enjoy it again the following day.
If you're feeding six people with smaller appetites, or serving another meat alongside your Turkey, that same bird may be perfectly adequate.
The important thing is to think beyond simply how many people are coming for dinner.
Boneless Turkey Crown Size Guide
Boneless Turkey Crowns have become increasingly popular over the years, and it's easy to understand why.
Made entirely from White Turkey Breast, they're carefully prepared, rolled and tied by our butchers, making them a wonderfully convenient option for Christmas dinner.
With no bones to worry about, they're particularly easy to carve and serve.
A few little touches from our butchery make them even more special.
Each Boneless Turkey Crown is vacuum-packed to help maintain its freshness, with a sprig of fresh Rosemary tucked inside for a lovely aromatic touch.
We also include a handy pop-up cooking timer, designed to activate when the Turkey reaches approximately 75°C.
It's a useful extra guide, but these timers aren't infallible. That's why every Turkey Crown comes with our Christmas Cooking Guide, which includes approximate cooking times based on the weight of your joint.
Our advice? As you approach the recommended cooking time, start checking your Turkey with a meat thermometer, even if the pop-up timer hasn't activated. Always check the thickest part of the meat to make sure it's reached a safe temperature before serving.
The pop-up timer is there to help, but a good meat thermometer is the best way to know when your Turkey is cooked to perfection.
Here's our serving guide:
|
Boneless Turkey Crown |
Minimum Weight |
Recommended Servings |
|
Small |
1.5kg+ |
2–4 people |
|
Medium |
2.3kg+ |
4–6 people |
|
Large |
4.5kg+ |
10–12 people |
As a general rule, we recommend around 500g of raw Boneless Turkey per person if you're planning for two generous meals - Christmas Day and Boxing Day.
If you're only concerned about Christmas dinner, or you're serving other meats, you can comfortably stretch those portions further.
That's why we've given you a range rather than an exact figure.
One other thing worth mentioning: the weights of Turnbull’s Turkey Boneless Crowns shown are our minimum advertised weights. The actual weight of your Turkey Crown may be a little larger.
What About Stuffed Boneless Turkey Crowns?
We also prepare Stuffed Boneless Turkey Crowns in our butchery.
Our butchers butterfly the Turkey Breast, add a generous layer of Stuffing, then carefully roll and tie the joint ready for roasting.
They're a lovely option if you want something a little different, without making Christmas dinner more complicated.
|
Stuffed Boneless Turkey Crown |
Minimum Weight |
Recommended Servings |
|
Medium |
3kg+ |
4–6 people |
|
Large |
5kg+ |
10–12 people |
The Stuffing is an addition to the Turkey Breast, rather than replacing some of the meat, so we'd recommend using the same serving guide as our Plain Boneless Turkey Crowns.
Whole Turkey or Boneless Turkey Crown - Which Should You Choose?
Now, I have to admit something.
I'm a traditionalist when it comes to Christmas dinner.
For me, there's something special about bringing a beautifully roasted Whole Turkey to the table.
I love the White Meat. I love the Dark Meat. And I love the whole tradition of cooking and carving a proper Christmas bird.
Our Whole Turkeys are Free-Range Bronze birds, raised by the Nelless family at Thistlyhaugh Farm near Longhorsley, here in Northumberland, and supplied to us through Northumberland Poultry.
They're a wonderful example of the quality of food produced here in our part of the world. But I also understand why so many customers now choose Boneless Turkey Crowns.
In fact, once some families make the switch, they rarely go back.
And I can understand why.
If everyone around your Christmas table prefers White Meat, there's little point in buying a Whole Turkey simply because it's traditional. A Boneless Turkey Crown gives you the Breast Meat you want, without the bones, and makes carving much more straightforward.
It's also worth understanding that our Boneless Turkey Crowns are prepared from standard White Turkey Breast, rather than the Free-Range Bronze birds we sell whole.
So, which would I recommend?
If you enjoy both White and Dark Meat, and love the traditional Christmas centrepiece, I'd choose a Whole Free-Range Bronze Turkey.
If you prefer White Meat and want something that's simple to carve, I'd choose a Boneless Turkey Crown.
There's no right or wrong answer. It's simply about what works best for your family.
Three Things to Think About Before Ordering Your Christmas Turkey
1. How Big Are Everyone's Appetites?
It's easy to assume that six people need a Turkey that serves six.
But six adults with hearty appetites are very different from a family gathering with young children.
That's why I always encourage customers to think about who's actually coming for dinner.
If you're feeding a table full of hungry adults, be generous with your portions.
If you're catering for smaller appetites, you may not need quite as much as you think.
2. Are You Serving Another Meat?
Christmas dinner is often about much more than just Turkey.
Perhaps you're cooking a Gammon Joint alongside it. Maybe you're serving a Rib of Beef, or another family favourite.
If Turkey isn't the only meat on the table, you can usually afford to be a little more conservative with the size you choose.
But if Turkey is the star of the show, I'd recommend allowing a little extra.
3. What Do You Want Left Over for Boxing Day?
This is the one I think people overlook.
And for me, it's probably the most important consideration of all.
Are you buying enough Turkey for Christmas dinner?
Or are you buying enough for Christmas dinner AND another lovely meal on Boxing Day?
Because there's a big difference.
Personally, I always plan for leftovers.
And not just a few slices for sandwiches.
I want enough Turkey to enjoy another proper meal.
Which brings me to one of my favourite parts of Christmas.
Why I Think Boxing Day Turkey Is Almost as Good as Christmas Dinner
I love Christmas dinner.
But if I'm being perfectly truthful, I think I enjoy Boxing Day almost as much.
The pressure of Christmas Day has passed. Everyone's a little more relaxed. And there's usually a fridge full of wonderful food waiting to be enjoyed.
My favourite Boxing Day meal is beautifully simple.
Slices of leftover Turkey, some good Sausage Meat Stuffing and a generous helping of Bubble and Squeak made from the previous day's vegetables.
That's it.
Nothing fancy. Just a really good, traditional meal. And if you've still got Turkey left after Boxing Day, there are plenty of other ways to enjoy it.
A homemade Turkey and Ham Pie is always a favourite.
Or here's another little tip I've used over the years…
Make yourself a few individual Turkey dinners for the freezer.
Take some freezer-safe food containers and portion out your leftover Turkey, Roast Potatoes, Vegetables and Stuffing.
You've then got a proper roast dinner tucked away in the freezer, ready to enjoy on a cold winters day in January or February.
Just make sure everything is cooled promptly and frozen safely. Refrigerate leftovers within two hours, eat refrigerated leftovers within 2-3 days ideally, or freeze them, and only reheat once until steaming hot throughout.
It's a lovely way of making Christmas last that little bit longer.
And certainly, better than throwing good food away.
Frequently Asked Questions About Christmas Turkey
What Size Turkey Do I Need for Four People?
For four people, I'd recommend a 4kg Whole Turkey, particularly if you want plenty left over for Boxing Day.
If you prefer White Meat, a Medium Boneless Turkey Crown weighing at least 2.3kg would be a generous alternative.
What Size Turkey Do I Need for Six People?
A 6kg Whole Turkey is a good choice for six people, allowing for a generous Christmas dinner and some leftovers.
A Medium Boneless Turkey Crown weighing at least 2.3kg can also serve six, although I'd consider a larger joint if everyone has hearty appetites and you want plenty for Boxing Day.
What Size Turkey Do I Need for Eight People?
For eight people, I'd recommend a 7kg Whole Turkey if you want a generous Christmas dinner with leftovers.
If you're choosing a Boneless Turkey Crown, our Large 4.5kg+ Joint would be an excellent option.
What Size Turkey Do I Need for Ten People?
For ten people, an 8kg Whole Turkey would be a sensible choice, particularly if you'd like some leftovers.
Alternatively, a Large Boneless Turkey Crown weighing at least 4.5kg should provide generous portions, depending on appetites.
Is a Boneless Turkey Crown Better Than a Whole Turkey?
Neither is necessarily better.
A Whole Turkey gives you both White and Dark Meat, along with the traditional Christmas centrepiece.
A Boneless Turkey Crown is all Breast Meat, with no bones, making it easier to carve and serve.
The best choice is the one that suits your family's preferences.
What's the Difference Between a Turkey Crown and a Boneless Turkey Crown?
A traditional Turkey Crown is the breast of the bird with the bone still in place, but the legs removed.
A Boneless Turkey Crown has the bones removed, making it much easier to carve.
At Turnbull's, we sell Boneless Turkey Crowns, prepared by our butchers from standard White Turkey Breast. They're available Plain or Stuffed.
Should I Buy a Bigger Turkey if I Want Leftovers?
Yes. If you want enough for a generous Boxing Day meal, I'd recommend choosing towards the lower end of our serving ranges.
It's always worth thinking about what you'd like to eat the following day before deciding on the size.
Chosen Your Turkey? Next Comes the Cooking!
Of course, choosing the right size Turkey is only part of the Christmas dinner challenge.
The next question is usually, "How do I cook it properly?"
And that's another question we hear every year.
Every Christmas Turkey purchased from Turnbull's comes with our Christmas Cooking Guide, giving you practical advice to help you prepare and roast your Turkey with confidence.
We'll also be sharing two more detailed guides here on our website shortly:
- How to Cook a Whole Free-Range Turkey
- How to Cook a Boneless Turkey Crown
We'll cover the preparation, cooking and all those little questions that come up when you're standing in the kitchen on Christmas morning.
Because a great Christmas dinner shouldn't be complicated.
A Final Word from Our Butchery Team
Choosing the right Christmas Turkey doesn't need to be difficult.
Think about how many people you're feeding, how big their appetites are, whether you're serving other meats and, perhaps most importantly, what you'd like left over for Boxing Day.
And if you're still unsure, just ask.
At Turnbull's Northumbrian Food Hall in Alnwick, our butchers are always happy to help you choose the right Turkey for your Christmas table.
We've been helping families with their Christmas dinners for generations, and we're always happy to share a little of that experience.
And whatever Turkey you choose, don't forget to leave enough for Boxing Day!
Mark Turnbull
Fifth Generation Butcher, Turnbull's Northumbrian Food Hall, Alnwick, Northumberland